Reading Order List β€” Book Series Reading Order Guide

Jenn McKinlay Reading Order

13 series Β· 71 books

Jenn McKinlay is a prolific American author known for her cozy mystery series featuring amateur sleuths in charming small-town settings. Her imaginative plots blend humor, romance, and clever twists across multiple beloved franchises including the Cupcake Bakery Mysteries, Decoupage Mysteries, and Library Lover's Mysteries series. Writing under several pen names, McKinlay has published nearly seventy books that appeal to readers seeking lighthearted whodunits with engaging characters and community-centered storytelling.

Are you Jenn McKinlay? Add a note for your readers β†’

Anthologies Series

Complete

1 book (2015–2015)

#Title
1

Bluff Point Romance Series

Complete

3 books (2017–2018)

The Bluff Point Romance series consists of three contemporary romance novels published between 2017 and 2018. This completed series should be read in publication order, beginning with About a Dog, followed by Barking Up the Wrong Tree, and concluding with Every Dog Has His Day. Jenn McKinlay's trilogy blends romance with the charming setting of Bluff Point, offering a satisfying arc across all three standalone-adjacent installments.

Start with About a Dog and read in order.

#Title
1
2
Cover of Barking Up the Wrong Tree
Barking Up the Wrong Tree
3
Cover of Every Dog Has His Day
Every Dog Has His Day

Books of Dubious Origin Series

Complete

1 book (2026–2026)

#Title
1
Witches of Questionable Intent

Cupcake Bakery Mystery Series

Ongoing

16 books (2010–2024)

The Cupcake Bakery Mystery series by Jenn McKinlay consists of 16 books published between 2010 and 2024, with the series ongoing. These cozy mysteries should be read in publication order, beginning with Sprinkle with Murder and continuing through the most recent installment. The series blends mystery and romance elements across titles including Buttercream Bump Off, Death by the Dozen, Red Velvet Revenge, and Sugar and Iced, among others.

Start with Sprinkle with Murder, the first of 16 books in the Cupcake Bakery Mystery series.

Start this series with Sprinkle with Murder

Buy Book 1 πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡ΈπŸŽ§ Listen free on Audible

Cupcake Bakery Mystery Non-Fiction Series

Complete

1 book (2022–2022)

#Title
1
Fairy Tale Cupcakes: Recipes from the Cupcake Bakery Mysteries(With: Christie Conlee)

Decoupage Mystery Series

Complete

3 books (2009–2011)

The Decoupage Mystery series by Jenn McKinlay consists of three complete novels published between 2009 and 2011, following the adventures of protagonist Lucy Lawrence. Readers should begin with Stuck on Murder and proceed through the remaining books in publication order for the intended narrative experience. This cozy mystery series blends elements of craft-based intrigue with traditional whodunit storytelling across its three interconnected installments.

Start with Stuck on Murder and read in order.

#Title
1
2
Cover of Cut to the Corpse(As: Lucy Lawrence)
Cut to the Corpse(As: Lucy Lawrence)
3

Good Buy Girls Mystery Series

Complete

5 books (2012–2015)

The Good Buy Girls Mystery series by Jenn McKinlay comprises five complete novels published between 2012 and 2015, written under the pen name Josie Belle. This mystery series should be read in publication order, beginning with 50% Off Murder and concluding with All Sales Final. The books blend mystery and thriller elements with touches of romance throughout the sequence.

Start with 50% Off Murder(As: Josie Belle), the first of 5 books in the Good Buy Girls Mystery series.

Start this series with 50% Off Murder(As: Josie Belle)

Buy Book 1 πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡ΈπŸŽ§ Listen free on Audible
#Title
1
Cover of 50% Off Murder(As: Josie Belle)
50% Off Murder(As: Josie Belle)
2
Cover of A Deal to Die For(As: Josie Belle)
A Deal to Die For(As: Josie Belle)
3
Cover of Buried in Bargains(As: Josie Belle)
Buried in Bargains(As: Josie Belle)
4
Cover of Marked Down for Murder(As: Josie Belle)
Marked Down for Murder(As: Josie Belle)
5
Cover of All Sales Final(As: Josie Belle)
All Sales Final(As: Josie Belle)

Happy Ever After Series

Complete

2 books (2019–2019)

Jenn McKinlay's Happy Ever After is a two-book complete series published in 2019. These standalone romance novels should be read in publication order, beginning with The Christmas Keeper followed by The Good Ones. The series blends fantasy and romance elements across its two entries.

Start with The Christmas Keeper and read in order.

Start this series with The Christmas Keeper

Buy Book 1 πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡ΈπŸŽ§ Listen free on Audible
#Title
1
The Christmas Keeper
2

Hat Shop Mystery Series

Likely Complete

7 books (2013–2023)

The Hat Shop Mystery series comprises seven books published between 2013 and 2023, blending mystery, fantasy, and romance across a complete collection. Beginning with Cloche and Dagger and concluding with Fatal Fascinator, the series should be read in publication order to follow the continuing storyline. Jenn McKinlay crafted this mystery series over a decade, with entries released roughly every one to two years throughout the 2010s and early 2020s.

Start with Cloche and Dagger, the first of 7 books in the Hat Shop Mystery series.

Start this series with Cloche and Dagger

Buy Book 1 πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡ΈπŸŽ§ Listen free on Audible

Library Lover's Mystery Series

Ongoing

17 books (2011–2026)

The Library Lover's Mystery series comprises seventeen books written by Jenn McKinlay, beginning with Books Can Be Deceiving in 2011 and continuing through 2026 as an ongoing series. These mysteries should be read in publication order to follow the progression of the story and characters. The series blends mystery, romance, and fantasy elements throughout its installments.

Start with Books Can Be Deceiving, the first of 17 books in the Library Lover's Mystery series.

Start this series with Books Can Be Deceiving

Buy Book 1 πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡ΈπŸŽ§ Listen free on Audible
#Title
1
Cover of Books Can Be Deceiving
Books Can Be Deceiving
2
Cover of Book, Line and Sinker
Book, Line and Sinker
3
4
5
6
7
8
Cover of Better Late Than Never
Better Late Than Never
9
10
11
12
13
14
Cover of The Plot and the Pendulum
The Plot and the Pendulum
15
A Merry Little Murder Plot
16
17

Museum of Literature Romance Series

Likely Complete

3 books (2022–2022)

Jenn McKinlay's Museum of Literature Romance series consists of three books published in 2022, blending fantasy, mystery, and romance elements. The trilogy appears to be complete and should be read in publication order beginning with It Happened One Christmas Eve, followed by Royal Valentine and The Attraction Distraction. Each installment builds on the previous entry, making sequential reading essential to fully appreciate the series' narrative arc.

Start with It Happened One Christmas Eve and read in order.

Start this series with It Happened One Christmas Eve

Buy Book 1 πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡ΈπŸŽ§ Listen free on Audible
#Title
1
It Happened One Christmas Eve
2
3
The Attraction Distraction

Short Story Collections Series

Complete

2 books (2002–2003)

Jenn McKinlay's short story collection series consists of two completed volumes published between 2002 and 2003. These collections blend fantasy, mystery, romance, and other genres across their stories. Read them in publication order, beginning with Perk Avenue / To Catch a Latte, followed by A Real Work of Art / Thick as Thieves.

Start with Perk Avenue / To Catch a Latte and read in order.

Start this series with Perk Avenue / To Catch a Latte

Buy Book 1 πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡ΈπŸŽ§ Listen free on Audible
#Title
1
Cover of Perk Avenue / To Catch a Latte
Perk Avenue / To Catch a Latte
2
Cover of A Real Work of Art / Thick as Thieves
A Real Work of Art / Thick as Thieves

Standalone Novels Series

Ongoing

10 books (2005–2027)

Jenn McKinlay's collection of standalone novels spans from 2005 to 2026 across fantasy, mystery, romance, and other genres, with nine entries currently published and the series ongoing. Each book functions as an independent story that can be enjoyed without reading others, though fans may prefer experiencing them in publication order starting with Keeping up Appearances. The most recent additions include Witches of Dubious Origin and The Summer Share, offering readers a growing selection of diverse narratives from this prolific author.

Start with Keeping up Appearances, the first of 9 books in the Standalone Novels series.

Start this series with Keeping up Appearances

Buy Book 1 πŸ‡ΊπŸ‡ΈπŸŽ§ Listen free on Audible

Frequently Asked Questions

How many books has Jenn McKinlay written?
Jenn McKinlay has written 71 books across 13 series. Their published works span from 2002 to 2027.
What is the first book in each Jenn McKinlay series?
Here are the first books in Jenn McKinlay's series: Bluff Point Romance: About a Dog; Cupcake Bakery Mystery: Sprinkle with Murder; Decoupage Mystery: Stuck on Murder; Good Buy Girls Mystery: 50% Off Murder(As: Josie Belle); Happy Ever After: The Christmas Keeper.
What order should I read Jenn McKinlay's books?
We recommend reading Jenn McKinlay's series in publication order. Each series can be read independently.
Is Jenn McKinlay still writing new books?
Yes, Jenn McKinlay has 3 ongoing series: Cupcake Bakery Mystery, Library Lover's Mystery, Standalone Novels.

You might also like