Elizabeth Penney Reading Order

23 books (2016–2018)

The Amish Inn Mysteries is a completed mystery series comprising 23 books published between 2016 and 2018, written by multiple authors including Elizabeth Penney, Rachael O. Phillips, Jan Fields, and others. The series should be read in publication order, beginning with A Silent Betrayal. Each installment features self-contained mysteries set within an Amish community backdrop, making the books accessible to readers who prefer episodic storytelling within a continuing setting.

Start with A Silent Betrayal(By: Rachael O. Phillips), the first of 23 books in the Amish Inn Mysteries series.

10 books (2015–2026)

Annie's Secret of the Quilt is an ongoing historical mystery series that began in 2015 and currently spans ten books. The series features contributions from multiple authors including Elizabeth Penney, DeAnna Julie Dodson, Kristi Holl, and Mary Blount Christian. Readers should follow the books in publication order, starting with Castle of Whispers and continuing through the most recent installment, Where Summer Never Comes, with the final book expected in 2026.

Start with Castle of Whispers, the first of 10 books in the Annie's Secret of the Quilt series.

12 books (2025–2025)

Annie's Sweet Intrigue is an ongoing mystery and historical fiction series comprising 12 books published in 2025, with contributions from multiple authors including Elizabeth Penney, DeAnna Julie Dodson, Virginia Smith, Sandra Orchard, and others. The series should be read in publication order, beginning with Betrayal of Trust and continuing through Web of Lies. Each installment features interconnected mysteries and intrigue woven throughout the collection.

Start with Betrayal of Trust(By: DeAnna Julie Dodson), the first of 12 books in the Annie's Sweet Intrigue series.

3 books (2015–2015)

Elizabeth Penney's Annie's Mysteries Unraveled is a completed two-book mystery series published in 2015. This historical fiction mystery series should be read in publication order, beginning with A Model Mystery followed by the second installment.

Start with A Model Mystery and read in order.

12 books (2013–2015)

Annie's Quilted Mystery is a 12-book mystery series published between 2013 and 2015, now complete. The series follows a cozy mystery format set within a quilting community and should be read in publication order, beginning with A Patchwork Murder. Each installment was written by different authors including Jan Fields, K.D. McCrite, and others, creating a collaborative mystery series that blends historical fiction elements with contemporary sleuthing.

Start with A Patchwork Murder(By: Jan Fields), the first of 12 books in the Annie’s Quilted Mystery series.

5 books (2020–2023)

Elizabeth Penney's Anthologies series comprises five mystery and historical fiction collections released between 2020 and 2023, appearing to be complete. These volumes function as standalone anthologies within the larger Cozy Case Files umbrella, so readers should follow publication order beginning with Volume 10, continuing through Volumes 8, 11, 16, and 19 to experience the stories as intended.

Start with Cozy Case Files Volume 10, the first of 5 books in the Anthologies series.

24 books (2016–2025)

3 books (2019–2021)

Elizabeth Penney's Apron Shop series consists of three mystery novels published between 2019 and 2021. The books should be read in publication order, beginning with Hems and Homicide, followed by Thread and Dead, and concluding with Bodies and Bows. The series appears to be complete. These historical mystery thrillers blend period detail with crime investigation in a cozy mystery style.

Start with Hems and Homicide and read in order.

#	Title
1	Hems and Homicide 2019Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Thread and Dead 2020Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	Bodies and Bows 2021Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

3 books (2027–2027)

The Beach Rose Cottage Mysteries is an ongoing historical mystery series by Elizabeth Penney with three books published in 2027. The series should be read in publication order, beginning with Secrets by the Sea and continuing through Tempest in a Teacup and The Stuff of Legend. New installments are planned for future release.

Start with Secrets by the Sea(By: Roseanna M. White) and read in order.

23 books (2017–2025)

The Cozy Case Files Mystery Sampler is an ongoing anthology series that collects mystery and thriller stories from multiple authors, with 22 volumes published between 2017 and 2025. Each volume contains short stories and novellas featuring different characters and settings, allowing readers to sample various cozy mystery styles in a single book. The series should be read in publication order, starting with Volume 1, to experience the collections as originally curated. This anthology series offers an ideal entry point for discovering new mystery authors and subgenres within the cozy mystery category.

Start with Cozy Case Files Volume 1(By: Ellie Alexander,Cynthia Riggs,Mindy Quigley), the first of 22 books in the Cozy Case Files Mystery Sampler series.

#	Title
1	Cozy Case Files Volume 1(By: Ellie Alexander,Cynthia Riggs,Mindy Quigley) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Cozy Case Files Volume 2(By: Carolyn Haines,Donna Andrews,Hannah Dennison,Cate Conte,Diane Kelly,E.J. Copperman,Ellie Alexander,Cynthia Riggs,Susan C. Shea,Mindy Quigley) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	Cozy Case Files Volume 3(By: M.C. Beaton,Donna Andrews,Ellie Alexander,Mindy Quigley) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	Cozy Case Files Volume 4(By: Parnell Hall,Shari Randall,Ellen Hart,Ellie Alexander,Frances Brody,Tessa Arlen,Vivien Chien,Julia Chapman,Paige Shelton,Jane K. Cleland,Mindy Quigley) 2018Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
5	Cozy Case Files Volume 5(By: Carolyn Haines,Donna Andrews,Carola Dunn,Sheila Connolly,Ellie Alexander,Susan C. Shea,Judith Flanders,Mindy Quigley,Auralee Wallace) 2018Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
6	Cozy Case Files Volume 6(By: Carolyn Haines,Donna Andrews,Cate Conte,Kylie Logan,Leonard Goldberg,Allison Montclair,Ellen Hart,Sheila Connolly,Mindy Quigley) 2019Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
7	Cozy Case Files Volume 7(By: Donna Andrews,Diane Kelly,Ellen Crosby,Ellie Alexander,Vivien Chien,Ashley Weaver,Mindy Quigley) 2019Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
8	Cozy Case Files Volume 10 2020Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
9	Cozy Case Files Volume 8 2020Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
10	Cozy Case Files Volume 9(By: Carolyn Haines,Donna Andrews,Hannah Dennison,Kylie Logan,Leonard Goldberg,Susanna Calkins,Allison Montclair,Ellie Alexander,Eve Calder,Mindy Quigley) 2020Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
11	Cozy Case Files Volume 11 2021Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
12	Cozy Case Files Volume 12(By: Carolyn Haines,Donna Andrews,Hannah Dennison,Cate Conte,Kylie Logan,Leonard Goldberg,Allison Montclair,Sheila Connolly,Ellie Alexander,Ashley Weaver,S.C. Perkins,Eve Calder,Jess Dylan,Mindy Quigley,Meri Allen) 2021Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
13	Cozy Case Files Volume 13(By: Mindy Quigley) 2021Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
14	Cozy Case Files Volume 14(By: Diane Kelly,Gigi Pandian,Ellie Alexander,Paige Shelton,Mindy Quigley,Korina Moss) 2022Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
15	Cozy Case Files Volume 15(By: Mindy Quigley) 2022Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
16	Cozy Case Files Volume 16 2022Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
17	Cozy Case Files Volume 17(By: Rhys Bowen,Diane Kelly,Gigi Pandian,Ellie Alexander,Paige Shelton,Jean-Luc Bannalec,Olivia Matthews,Olivia Blacke,Mindy Quigley,Clare Broyles,Korina Moss,Anastasia Hastings) 2023Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
18	Cozy Case Files, Volume 18(By: Carolyn Haines,Donna Andrews,Leonard Goldberg,Allison Montclair,Vivien Chien,Olivia Matthews,Olivia Blacke,Mindy Quigley,Meri Allen,Katharine Schellman,Korina Moss) 2023Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
19	Cozy Case Files, Volume 19 2023Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
20	Cozy Case Files, Volume 20(By: Rhys Bowen,Gigi Pandian,Ellie Alexander,Paige Shelton,Olivia Matthews,Jennifer J. Chow,Olivia Blacke,Mindy Quigley,Clare Broyles,Anastasia Hastings) 2024Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
21	Cozy Case Files, Volume 22 2024Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
22	Cozy Case Files, Volume 23(By: Diane Kelly,Gigi Pandian,Ellie Alexander,Vivien Chien,Paige Shelton,Jennifer J. Chow) 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
23	Cozy Case Files, Volume 24 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

8 books (2026–2027)

The Gift Shop Mysteries series by Elizabeth Penney consists of five books published between 2026 and 2027, with the series still ongoing. These mystery and historical fiction novels should be read in publication order, beginning with A Gift in Time. The series combines contemporary mystery elements with historical intrigue centered around a gift shop setting.

Start with A Gift in Time(By: Shaen Layle), the first of 5 books in the Gift Shop Mysteries series.

23 books (2019–2021)

The Inn at Magnolia Harbor is a mystery and thriller series comprising 23 books published between 2019 and 2021, written by Elizabeth Penney and a roster of additional authors. The series appears to be complete and should be read in publication order, beginning with Binding Vows. Each standalone mystery is set against the backdrop of the inn, allowing readers to enjoy entries individually while experiencing the full narrative arc across the complete sequence.

Start with Binding Vows(By: Gayle Roper), the first of 23 books in the Inn at Magnolia Harbor series.

15 books (2026–2026)

The Irish Tearoom Mysteries is an ongoing cozy mystery series set in Ireland, blending historical fiction with contemporary detective work. Currently comprising 15 books published in 2026, the series follows cases connected to an Irish tearoom setting and should be read in publication order to fully appreciate the unfolding narrative. With multiple authors contributing to the series, each book offers a standalone mystery while building on the broader tapestry of the tearoom's history and characters. Begin with A Deadly Brew and continue through Yule Pay Dearly to experience the complete series as intended.

Start with A Deadly Brew(By: Virginia Smith), the first of 15 books in the Irish Tearoom Mysteries series.

19 books (2021–2022)

The Miracles & Mysteries of Mercy Hospital series consists of 19 mystery and historical fiction novels published between 2021 and 2022, appearing to be complete. Written by multiple authors including Elizabeth Penney, Tia McCollors, Leslie Gould, Gabrielle Meyer, and others, the series should be read in publication order beginning with 'Twas the Clue Before Christmas. Each standalone mystery is set within the same hospital setting, allowing readers to enjoy individual stories or follow the series from start to finish.

Start with 'Twas the Clue Before Christmas(By: Tia McCollors), the first of 19 books in the Miracles & Mysteries of Mercy Hospital series.

12 books (2022–2025)

The Mysteries of Aspen Falls is an ongoing cozy mystery series featuring twelve books published between 2022 and 2025, with contributions from multiple authors including Elizabeth Penney, DeAnna Julie Dodson, Johnnie Alexander, Tara Randel, and Gayle Roper. The series blends mystery and thriller elements with historical fiction, and should be read in publication order beginning with Hounded By The Past. New installments continue to be released as the series expands.

Start with Hounded By The Past(By: DeAnna Julie Dodson), the first of 12 books in the Mysteries of Aspen Falls series.

20 books (2025–2026)

The Mysteries of Blackberry Valley is an ongoing mystery series set to include 14 books published between 2025 and 2026. The series features multiple authors contributing individual mysteries within a shared setting, and should be read in publication order beginning with A Likely Story. Each entry stands as its own mystery while contributing to the broader tapestry of the Blackberry Valley community.

Start with A Likely Story(By: Roseanna M. White), the first of 14 books in the Mysteries of Blackberry Valley series.

#	Title
1	A Likely Story(By: Roseanna M. White) 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Crooks and Christmas Cookies(By: Stephanie Coleman) 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	Out of the Depths(By: Beth Adams) 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	Run for the Roses(By: Cate Nolan) 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
5	Seeds of Suspicion 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
6	Smoke and Mirrors(By: Laura Bradford) 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
7	The Key Question(By: Virginia Smith,Beth Adams) 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
8	Where There's Smoke(By: Laura Bradford) 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
9	A Brush with Danger(By: Beth Adams) 2026Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
10	Forged in Fire(By: Stephanie Coleman) 2026Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
11	Lost in a Book(By: Becky Melby) 2026Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
12	No Love Lost(By: Becky Melby) 2026Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
13	Pumpkin Peril 2026Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
14	Snowbound Secrets(By: Cate Nolan) 2026Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
15	That Christmas Feeling(By: Beth Adams) 2026Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
16	The Big Picture(By: Laura Bradford) 2026Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
17	The Cookbook Clue 2026Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
18	The Final Cut(By: Roseanna M. White) 2026Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
19	The Mandolin Mystery(By: Cate Nolan) 2026Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
20	The Pilfered Pearls(By: Stephanie Coleman) 2026Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

24 books (2024–2026)

The Mysteries of Cobble Hill Farm is an ongoing mystery series that began in 2024 and currently contains 15 published books. This collaborative series features contributions from multiple authors including Laura Bradford, Beth Adams, Sandra Orchard, and others, blending mystery and historical fiction elements. Readers should follow the books in their publication order to experience the developing storylines at Cobble Hill Farm, beginning with A Little Bird Told Me and continuing through the most recently released entries.

Start with A Little Bird Told Me(By: Laura Bradford), the first of 15 books in the Mysteries of Cobble Hill Farm series.

24 books (2017–2019)

The Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard is a completed 24-book mystery series published between 2017 and 2019, written by multiple authors including Elizabeth Penney, Ruth Logan Herne, Beth Adams, and others. The series should be read in publication order, beginning with A Light in the Darkness. Each book features mysteries set on Martha's Vineyard with contributions from various mystery and historical fiction authors.

Start with A Light in the Darkness(By: Ruth Logan Herne), the first of 24 books in the Mysteries of Martha's Vineyard series.

2 books (2026–2027)

12 books (2025–2025)

The Rose Cottage Book Club series is an ongoing mystery and historical fiction collection featuring twelve books published in 2025, written by multiple authors including Elizabeth Penney, Barbara Josselsohn, Tara Johnson, Jeanette Hanscome, Jan Fields, Mary Alford, and Jolyn Sharp. The series should be read in publication order, beginning with A New Chapter and continuing through Written in Time. Each installment follows the interconnected mysteries and literary adventures of the book club members set against historical backdrops.

Start with A New Chapter(By: Barbara Josselsohn), the first of 12 books in the Rose Cottage Book Club series.

24 books (2020–2021)

The Scottish Bakehouse Mysteries series comprises 24 mystery novels published between 2020 and 2021, written by multiple authors including Elizabeth Penney, Rachael O. Phillips, Jan Fields, Sandra Orchard, and Gayle Roper. The series appears to be complete and should be read in publication order, beginning with A Faerie Dangerous Game. These cozy mysteries blend Scottish settings with bakehouse intrigue, offering readers a collection of interconnected stories centered around a bakery in Scotland.

Start with A Faerie Dangerous Game(By: Rachael O. Phillips), the first of 24 books in the Scottish Bakehouse Mysteries series.

24 books (2017–2019)

The Secrets of the Castleton Manor Library is a 24-book mystery series published between 2017 and 2019, now complete. Written by multiple authors including Marlene Chase, Jan Fields, DeAnna Julie Dodson, Margaret Welch, Allie Pleiter, Catherine Dilts, and Sandra Orchard, the series blends mystery and historical fiction elements. Readers should begin with A Crime Well Versed and follow the books in publication order to experience the full narrative arc. Each installment features interwoven mysteries tied to the Castleton Manor library setting.

Start with A Crime Well Versed(By: Marlene Chase), the first of 24 books in the Secrets of the Castleton Manor Library series.

2 books (2023–2026)

5 books (2021–2025)

The Cambridge Bookshop is an ongoing mystery series by Elizabeth Penney consisting of five books published between 2021 and 2025. This historical fiction series should be read in publication order, beginning with Chapter and Curse and continuing through A Treacherous Tale, The Fatal Folio, Madrigals and Mayhem, and Vows and Villainy. The series blends mystery and historical elements set around the Cambridge Bookshop location.

Start with Chapter and Curse, the first of 5 books in the The Cambridge Bookshop series.

#	Title
1	Chapter and Curse 2021Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	A Treacherous Tale 2022Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	The Fatal Folio 2023Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	Madrigals and Mayhem 2024Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
5	Vows and Villainy 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

1 book (2025–2025)

#	Title
1	Bodies and Battlements 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

16 books (2018–2025)

The Victorian Mansion Flower Shop Mysteries is a collaborative mystery series set in a historical flower shop, featuring contributions from multiple authors including Elizabeth Penney, Grace Marcello, Gayle Roper, Johnnie Alexander, Sandra Orchard, Katy Lee, Kristi Holl, Lynette Sowell, and Jan Fields. Comprising 15 books published between 2018 and 2021, the series blends historical fiction with contemporary mystery elements. The series appears to be complete and should be read in publication order, beginning with A Cultivated Crime.

Start with A Cultivated Crime(By: Grace Marcello), the first of 15 books in the Victorian Mansion Flower Shop Mysteries series.