Amy Lillard Reading Order

1 book (2014–2014)

4 books (2017–2022)

Start with Kappy King and the Puppy Kaper, the first of 4 books in the Amish Mystery series.

#	Title
1	Kappy King and the Puppy Kaper 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Kappy King and the Pickle Kaper 2018Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	Kappy King and the Pie Kaper 2018Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	This Little Piggy 2022Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

4 books (2018–2020)

Start with A Home for Hannah, the first of 4 books in the Amish of Pontotoc series.

#	Title
1	A Home for Hannah 2018Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	A Love for Leah 2018Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	A Family for Gracie 2019Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	An Amish Husband for Tillie 2020Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

12 books (2013–2015)

Start with A Patchwork Murder(By: Jan Fields), the first of 12 books in the Annie’s Quilted Mystery series.

3 books (2015–2024)

Start with The 12 Brides of Christmas Collection and read in order.

#	Title
1	The 12 Brides of Christmas Collection 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	The Oregon Trail Romance Collection 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	A Lancaster Amish Christmas 2024Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

3 books (2016–2023)

Start with Loving a Lawman and read in order.

#	Title
1	Loving a Lawman 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Healing a Heart 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	Besting the Bull Rider 2023Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

4 books (2012–2023)

Start with Saving Gideon, the first of 4 books in the Clover Ridge series.

#	Title
1	Saving Gideon 2012Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Katie's Choice 2013Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	Gabriel's Bride 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	John Paul in Love 2023Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

4 books (2019–2019)

Start with Jessie and James(By: Jennifer Beckstrand), the first of 4 books in the Gold Diggers series.

#	Title
1	Jessie and James(By: Jennifer Beckstrand) 2019Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Jewel's Gold(By: Caryl McAdoo) 2019Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	No Greater Treasure 2019Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	The Trouble with Nancy(By: Chautona Havig) 2019Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

1 book (2014–2014)

#	Title
1	Take Me Back to Texas 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

3 books (2019–2021)

Start with Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder and read in order.

#	Title
1	Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder 2019Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	A Murder Between the Pages 2020Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	A Murder Like No Author 2021Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

3 books (2015–2020)

Start with Southern Comfort and read in order.

#	Title
1	Southern Comfort 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Southern Hospitality 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	Southern Charm 2020Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

4 books (2021–2023)

Start with Marry Me, Millie, the first of 4 books in the Paradise Valley series.

#	Title
1	Marry Me, Millie 2021Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	The Amish Matchmaker 2022Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	One More Time for Joy 2023Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	When Hattie Finds Love 2023Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

3 books (2016–2017)

Start with More Than Friendship and read in order.

1 book (2017–2017)

2 books (2015–2017)

Start with The Amish Christmas Sleigh(With: Molly Jebber) and read in order.

#	Title
1	The Amish Christmas Sleigh(With: Molly Jebber) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Amish Brides(With: Jennifer Beckstrand,Molly Jebber) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

14 books (2013–2026)

Start with All You Need Is Love, the first of 13 books in the Standalone Novels series.

#	Title
1	All You Need Is Love 2013Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Brodie's Bride(As: Amie Louellen) 2013Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	Can't Buy Me Love 2013Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	Love Potion Me, Baby(As:Amie Louellen) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
5	The Trouble with Millionaires(As: Amie Louellen) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
6	Blame It on Texas 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
7	Ten Reasons Not to Date a Cop(As:Amie Louellen) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
8	Forget Me Not, Baby 2022Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
9	A Million to One 2023Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
10	The Amish Christmas Promise 2023Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
11	The Amish Bachelor's Promise 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
12	The Amish Nanny's Secret 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
13	The Secrets We Keep 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
14	The Amish Rancher's Return 2026Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

27 books (2015–2025)

Start with A Season of Secrets(By: Elizabeth Adams), the first of 27 books in the Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries series.

#	Title
1	A Season of Secrets(By: Elizabeth Adams) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Blessing in Disguise(By: Nancy Mehl) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	O Little Town of Sugarcreek(By: Amy Lee Lillard) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	Off the Beaten Path(By: Annalisa Daughety) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
5	Peace Like a River(By: Olivia Newport) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
6	The Buggy Before the Horse(By: Tricia Goyer) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
7	Where Hope Dwells(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
8	A Stitch in Time(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
9	All Abuzz at the Honey Bee(By: Nancy Mehl) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
10	Earthly Treasures(By: Annalisa Daughety) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
11	Home Sweet Sugarcreek(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
12	In a Jam(By: Elizabeth Adams) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
13	Mason Jar Mayhem(By: Cara C. Putman) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
14	No Time for Trouble(By: Olivia Newport) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
15	Shoo, FLY, Shoo 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
16	Simply Vanished(By: Nancy Mehl) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
17	Stranger Things Have Happened 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
18	When There's a Will(By: Elizabeth Adams) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
19	A Play On Words(By: Emily Thomas) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
20	A Tempting Taste Of Mystery(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
21	Digging Up Doubts(By: Olivia Newport) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
22	Horse Sense and Sensibility(By: Nancy Mehl) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
23	In the Fullness of Time(By: Elizabeth Adams) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
24	Secrets Plain and Simple(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) 2018Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
25	When Angels Whisper(By: Nancy Mehl) 2022Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
26	Hark! The Herald Angel Falls(By: Tricia Goyer) 2024Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
27	O Little Town of Sugarcreek 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

3 books (2022–2024)

Start with Dairy, Dairy, Quite Contrary and read in order.

#	Title
1	Dairy, Dairy, Quite Contrary 2022Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	A Murder of Aspic Proportions 2023Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	A Murder for the Sages 2024Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

19 books (2014–2014)

Start with The Advent Bride(By: Mary Connealy), the first of 12 books in the The 12 Brides of Christmas series.

#	Title
1	The Advent Bride(By: Mary Connealy) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	The Advent Bride(By: Mary Connealy,Diana Lesire Brandmeyer) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	The Christmas Star Bride(By: Amanda Cabot) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	The Christmas Star Bride(By: Diana Lesire Brandmeyer,Amanda Cabot) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
5	The Christmas Tree Bride(By: Susan Page Davis) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
6	The Evergreen Bride(By: Pam Hillman) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
7	The Festive Bride(By: Diana Lesire Brandmeyer) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
8	The Fruitcake Bride(By: Vickie McDonough) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
9	The Fruitcake Bride(By: Vickie McDonough,Diana Lesire Brandmeyer) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
10	The Gift-Wrapped Bride(By: Diana Lesire Brandmeyer,Maureen Lang) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
11	The Gift-Wrapped Bride(By: Maureen Lang) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
12	The Gingerbread Bride 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
13	The Nativity Bride(By: Diana Lesire Brandmeyer,Miralee Ferrell) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
14	The Nativity Bride(By: Miralee Ferrell) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
15	The Nutcracker Bride(By: Margaret Brownley) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
16	The Snowbound Bride(By: Davalynn Spencer) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
17	The Snowbound Bride(By: Diana Lesire Brandmeyer,Davalynn Spencer) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
18	The Yuletide Bride(By: Michelle Ule) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
19	The Yuletide Bride(By: Michelle Ule,Diana Lesire Brandmeyer) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

12 books (2015–2021)

Start with Old West Summer Brides(By: Susan Page Davis,Mary Connealy,Miralee Ferrell,Davalynn Spencer), the first of 12 books in the The 12 Brides of Summer series.

#	Title
1	Old West Summer Brides(By: Susan Page Davis,Mary Connealy,Miralee Ferrell,Davalynn Spencer) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	The Sunbonnet Bride(By: Michelle Ule) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	The Columbine Bride(By: Davalynn Spencer) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	The County Fair Bride(By: Vickie McDonough) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
5	The Dogwood Blossom Bride(By: Miralee Ferrell) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
6	The Fourth of July Bride(By: Amanda Cabot) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
7	Blue Moon Bride(By: Susan Page Davis) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
8	The Honey Bride(By: Diana Lesire Brandmeyer) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
9	The Wildflower Bride 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
10	The Summer Harvest Bride(By: Maureen Lang) 2019Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
11	Dog Days of Summer Bride(By: Margaret Brownley) 2020Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
12	The Lumberjack's Bride(By: Pam Hillman) 2021Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

1 book (2015–2015)

#	Title
1	Pattern of Betrayal 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

11 books (2014–2021)

Start with Caroline's Secret, the first of 11 books in the Wells Landing series.

#	Title
1	Caroline's Secret 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Courting Emily 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	Lorie's Heart 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	Just Plain Sadie 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
5	Titus Returns 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
6	Marrying Jonah 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
7	A Wells Landing Christmas 2018Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
8	The Quilting Circle 2018Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
9	Loving Jenna 2020Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
10	Romancing Nadine 2020Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
11	A New Love for Charlotte 2021Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible