Amy Lillard Reading Order

1 book (2014–2014)

4 books (2017–2022)

Amy Lillard's Amish Mystery series consists of four books published between 2017 and 2022, following publication order for reading. The series appears to be complete, beginning with Kappy King and the Puppy Kaper and concluding with This Little Piggy. These mysteries blend elements of thriller, romance, and literary fiction within an Amish setting, offering readers a unique combination of genres set against a distinctive cultural backdrop.

Start with Kappy King and the Puppy Kaper, the first of 4 books in the Amish Mystery series.

#	Title
1	Kappy King and the Puppy Kaper 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Kappy King and the Pickle Kaper 2018Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	Kappy King and the Pie Kaper 2018Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	This Little Piggy 2022Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

4 books (2018–2020)

The Amish of Pontotoc is a four-book series by Amy Lillard featuring mystery, romance, and literary fiction elements set within an Amish community. Published between 2018 and 2020, the series is now complete and should be read in publication order, beginning with A Home for Hannah and continuing through A Love for Leah, A Family for Gracie, and An Amish Husband for Tillie.

Start with A Home for Hannah, the first of 4 books in the Amish of Pontotoc series.

#	Title
1	A Home for Hannah 2018Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	A Love for Leah 2018Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	A Family for Gracie 2019Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	An Amish Husband for Tillie 2020Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

12 books (2013–2015)

Annie's Quilted Mystery is a complete cozy mystery series comprising twelve books published between 2013 and 2015. The series was written by multiple authors including Amy Lillard, Jan Fields, K.D. McCrite, Elizabeth Penney, Rachael O. Phillips, and Donna Kelly. Readers should follow the books in publication order to experience the full narrative arc. The series blends mystery and romance elements throughout its twelve-book run.

Start with A Patchwork Murder(By: Jan Fields), the first of 12 books in the Annie’s Quilted Mystery series.

3 books (2015–2024)

Amy Lillard's anthology series spans from 2015 to 2024 with three collections published so far, with more forthcoming. These books blend mystery, thriller, romance, and literary fiction elements across their stories. Readers should follow publication order, beginning with The 12 Brides of Christmas Collection, then moving to The Oregon Trail Romance Collection, and continuing with A Lancaster Amish Christmas.

Start with The 12 Brides of Christmas Collection and read in order.

#	Title
1	The 12 Brides of Christmas Collection 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	The Oregon Trail Romance Collection 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	A Lancaster Amish Christmas 2024Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

3 books (2016–2023)

The Cattle Creek series by Amy Lillard comprises three standalone romance and mystery novels published between 2016 and 2023. The three books—Loving a Lawman, Healing a Heart, and Besting the Bull Rider—should be read in publication order for the best experience. The series appears to be complete, offering readers a finished story arc within the rural Cattle Creek setting.

Start with Loving a Lawman and read in order.

#	Title
1	Loving a Lawman 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Healing a Heart 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	Besting the Bull Rider 2023Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

4 books (2012–2023)

The Clover Ridge series by Amy Lillard comprises four books published between 2012 and 2023, blending mystery, romance, and literary fiction. The series appears to be complete and should be read in publication order, beginning with Saving Gideon, followed by Katie's Choice, Gabriel's Bride, and John Paul in Love. These standalone-adjacent novels are interconnected through their shared setting and characters, offering readers a richly layered exploration of the Clover Ridge community.

Start with Saving Gideon, the first of 4 books in the Clover Ridge series.

#	Title
1	Saving Gideon 2012Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Katie's Choice 2013Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	Gabriel's Bride 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	John Paul in Love 2023Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

4 books (2019–2019)

The Gold Diggers series is a four-book mystery and romance collection published in 2019 and now complete. Each book stands as an independent entry that can be enjoyed on its own, though reading in publication order—beginning with Jessie and James—provides the intended experience. The series spans mystery, thriller, romance, and literary fiction elements across its four installments.

Start with Jessie and James(By: Jennifer Beckstrand), the first of 4 books in the Gold Diggers series.

#	Title
1	Jessie and James(By: Jennifer Beckstrand) 2019Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Jewel's Gold(By: Caryl McAdoo) 2019Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	No Greater Treasure 2019Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	The Trouble with Nancy(By: Chautona Havig) 2019Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

1 book (2014–2014)

#	Title
1	Take Me Back to Texas 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

3 books (2019–2021)

Amy Lillard's Main Street Book Club Mysteries series consists of three books published between 2019 and 2021 and should be read in publication order. The series appears to be complete, with the three entries being Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder, A Murder Between the Pages, and A Murder Like No Author. Blending mystery, romance, and literary fiction, this cozy mystery series follows a book club as members encounter crimes in their community.

Start with Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder and read in order.

#	Title
1	Can't Judge a Book By Its Murder 2019Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	A Murder Between the Pages 2020Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	A Murder Like No Author 2021Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

3 books (2015–2020)

The Mayhem & Magnolias series consists of three complete books by Amy Lillard, published between 2015 and 2020. These mystery and romance novels set in the South should be read in publication order, beginning with Southern Comfort, followed by Southern Hospitality, and concluding with Southern Charm. The series blends elements of thriller and literary fiction with its Southern setting and character-driven narrative.

Start with Southern Comfort and read in order.

#	Title
1	Southern Comfort 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Southern Hospitality 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	Southern Charm 2020Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

4 books (2021–2023)

The Paradise Valley series by Amy Lillard consists of four books published between 2021 and 2023, blending mystery, thriller, romance, and literary fiction elements. The books should be read in publication order, beginning with Marry Me, Millie and continuing through The Amish Matchmaker, One More Time for Joy, and When Hattie Finds Love. The series appears to be complete as of 2023.

Start with Marry Me, Millie, the first of 4 books in the Paradise Valley series.

#	Title
1	Marry Me, Millie 2021Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	The Amish Matchmaker 2022Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	One More Time for Joy 2023Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	When Hattie Finds Love 2023Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

3 books (2016–2017)

Amy Lillard's Quilting Circle is a three-book mystery and romance series completed between 2016 and 2017. The books should be read in publication order, beginning with More Than Friendship, followed by More Than a Promise, and concluding with More Than a Marriage. This complete series blends elements of thriller, romance, and literary fiction.

Start with More Than Friendship and read in order.

1 book (2017–2017)

2 books (2015–2017)

Amy Lillard has completed a two-book collection of short stories published between 2015 and 2017. These collaborative works blend mystery, thriller, romance, and literary fiction elements. The series should be read in publication order, beginning with The Amish Christmas Sleigh, a collaborative effort with Molly Jebber, followed by Amish Brides, which features contributions from both Jebber and Jennifer Beckstrand.

Start with The Amish Christmas Sleigh(With: Molly Jebber) and read in order.

#	Title
1	The Amish Christmas Sleigh(With: Molly Jebber) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Amish Brides(With: Jennifer Beckstrand,Molly Jebber) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

14 books (2013–2026)

Amy Lillard has written 13 standalone novels published between 2013 and 2025, with the series still ongoing. These mystery, thriller, and romance books should be read in publication order, beginning with All You Need Is Love. The collection includes works published under both the Amy Lillard and Amie Louellen pen names, spanning contemporary romantic mysteries and Amish-themed narratives.

Start with All You Need Is Love, the first of 13 books in the Standalone Novels series.

#	Title
1	All You Need Is Love 2013Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Brodie's Bride(As: Amie Louellen) 2013Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	Can't Buy Me Love 2013Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	Love Potion Me, Baby(As:Amie Louellen) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
5	The Trouble with Millionaires(As: Amie Louellen) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
6	Blame It on Texas 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
7	Ten Reasons Not to Date a Cop(As:Amie Louellen) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
8	Forget Me Not, Baby 2022Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
9	A Million to One 2023Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
10	The Amish Christmas Promise 2023Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
11	The Amish Bachelor's Promise 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
12	The Amish Nanny's Secret 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
13	The Secrets We Keep 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
14	The Amish Rancher's Return 2026Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

27 books (2015–2025)

The Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries is an ongoing cozy mystery series set in Ohio's Amish country, featuring 27 books published from 2015 to 2025 by multiple authors including Amy Lillard, Elizabeth Adams, Nancy Mehl, and others. The series follows various mysteries unfolding in the close-knit community of Sugarcreek, blending elements of mystery, romance, and literary fiction. Books should be read in publication order to fully appreciate the interconnected storylines and character development across the expanding cast. Start with A Season of Secrets and continue through the series to follow the ongoing narratives within this charming Amish setting.

Start with A Season of Secrets(By: Elizabeth Adams), the first of 27 books in the Sugarcreek Amish Mysteries series.

#	Title
1	A Season of Secrets(By: Elizabeth Adams) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Blessing in Disguise(By: Nancy Mehl) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	O Little Town of Sugarcreek(By: Amy Lee Lillard) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	Off the Beaten Path(By: Annalisa Daughety) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
5	Peace Like a River(By: Olivia Newport) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
6	The Buggy Before the Horse(By: Tricia Goyer) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
7	Where Hope Dwells(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
8	A Stitch in Time(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
9	All Abuzz at the Honey Bee(By: Nancy Mehl) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
10	Earthly Treasures(By: Annalisa Daughety) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
11	Home Sweet Sugarcreek(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
12	In a Jam(By: Elizabeth Adams) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
13	Mason Jar Mayhem(By: Cara C. Putman) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
14	No Time for Trouble(By: Olivia Newport) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
15	Shoo, FLY, Shoo 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
16	Simply Vanished(By: Nancy Mehl) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
17	Stranger Things Have Happened 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
18	When There's a Will(By: Elizabeth Adams) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
19	A Play On Words(By: Emily Thomas) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
20	A Tempting Taste Of Mystery(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
21	Digging Up Doubts(By: Olivia Newport) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
22	Horse Sense and Sensibility(By: Nancy Mehl) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
23	In the Fullness of Time(By: Elizabeth Adams) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
24	Secrets Plain and Simple(By: Elizabeth Ludwig) 2018Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
25	When Angels Whisper(By: Nancy Mehl) 2022Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
26	Hark! The Herald Angel Falls(By: Tricia Goyer) 2024Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
27	O Little Town of Sugarcreek 2025Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

3 books (2022–2024)

The Sunflower Café Mystery series by Amy Lillard consists of three books published between 2022 and 2024, with the series still ongoing. These cozy mysteries blending elements of romance and literary fiction should be read in publication order, beginning with Dairy, Dairy, Quite Contrary, followed by A Murder of Aspic Proportions and A Murder for the Sages.

Start with Dairy, Dairy, Quite Contrary and read in order.

#	Title
1	Dairy, Dairy, Quite Contrary 2022Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	A Murder of Aspic Proportions 2023Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	A Murder for the Sages 2024Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

19 books (2014–2014)

The 12 Brides of Christmas is a complete series of twelve festive romance novellas published in 2014 by multiple authors including Mary Connealy, Amanda Cabot, Susan Page Davis, and others. Each standalone story follows a different bride during the Christmas season, allowing readers to enjoy the collection in any order, though publication order is recommended for the intended reading experience. This anthology series blends romance with holiday themes and should be read starting with The Advent Bride.

Start with The Advent Bride(By: Mary Connealy), the first of 12 books in the The 12 Brides of Christmas series.

#	Title
1	The Advent Bride(By: Mary Connealy) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	The Advent Bride(By: Mary Connealy,Diana Lesire Brandmeyer) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	The Christmas Star Bride(By: Amanda Cabot) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	The Christmas Star Bride(By: Diana Lesire Brandmeyer,Amanda Cabot) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
5	The Christmas Tree Bride(By: Susan Page Davis) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
6	The Evergreen Bride(By: Pam Hillman) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
7	The Festive Bride(By: Diana Lesire Brandmeyer) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
8	The Fruitcake Bride(By: Vickie McDonough) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
9	The Fruitcake Bride(By: Vickie McDonough,Diana Lesire Brandmeyer) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
10	The Gift-Wrapped Bride(By: Diana Lesire Brandmeyer,Maureen Lang) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
11	The Gift-Wrapped Bride(By: Maureen Lang) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
12	The Gingerbread Bride 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
13	The Nativity Bride(By: Diana Lesire Brandmeyer,Miralee Ferrell) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
14	The Nativity Bride(By: Miralee Ferrell) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
15	The Nutcracker Bride(By: Margaret Brownley) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
16	The Snowbound Bride(By: Davalynn Spencer) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
17	The Snowbound Bride(By: Diana Lesire Brandmeyer,Davalynn Spencer) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
18	The Yuletide Bride(By: Michelle Ule) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
19	The Yuletide Bride(By: Michelle Ule,Diana Lesire Brandmeyer) 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

12 books (2015–2021)

The 12 Brides of Summer is a twelve-book historical romance series published between 2015 and 2021, featuring standalone stories connected by a summer wedding theme set in the Old West. The series brings together multiple authors including Susan Page Davis, Mary Connealy, Miralee Ferrell, Davalynn Spencer, Michelle Ule, Vickie McDonough, Amanda Cabot, Diana Lesire Brandmeyer, Maureen Lang, Margaret Brownley, and Pam Hillman. Each installment can be read independently, though reading in publication order provides the intended experience. The series appears to be complete as of 2021.

Start with Old West Summer Brides(By: Susan Page Davis,Mary Connealy,Miralee Ferrell,Davalynn Spencer), the first of 12 books in the The 12 Brides of Summer series.

#	Title
1	Old West Summer Brides(By: Susan Page Davis,Mary Connealy,Miralee Ferrell,Davalynn Spencer) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	The Sunbonnet Bride(By: Michelle Ule) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	The Columbine Bride(By: Davalynn Spencer) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	The County Fair Bride(By: Vickie McDonough) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
5	The Dogwood Blossom Bride(By: Miralee Ferrell) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
6	The Fourth of July Bride(By: Amanda Cabot) 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
7	Blue Moon Bride(By: Susan Page Davis) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
8	The Honey Bride(By: Diana Lesire Brandmeyer) 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
9	The Wildflower Bride 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
10	The Summer Harvest Bride(By: Maureen Lang) 2019Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
11	Dog Days of Summer Bride(By: Margaret Brownley) 2020Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
12	The Lumberjack's Bride(By: Pam Hillman) 2021Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

3 books (2015–2015)

#	Title
1	Pattern of Betrayal 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Pattern of Betrayal(With: Mae Fox) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	Threads of Deceit(By: Jan Fields,Mae Fox) 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible

11 books (2014–2021)

The Wells Landing series by Amy Lillard comprises eleven books published between 2014 and 2021, blending mystery, romance, and literary fiction elements. The series follows interconnected characters within an Amish community and should be read in publication order, beginning with Caroline's Secret and concluding with A New Love for Charlotte. The series appears to be complete as of 2021. This collection includes a standalone Christmas novella that fits chronologically within the larger narrative arc.

Start with Caroline's Secret, the first of 11 books in the Wells Landing series.

#	Title
1	Caroline's Secret 2014Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
2	Courting Emily 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
3	Lorie's Heart 2015Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
4	Just Plain Sadie 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
5	Titus Returns 2016Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
6	Marrying Jonah 2017Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
7	A Wells Landing Christmas 2018Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
8	The Quilting Circle 2018Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
9	Loving Jenna 2020Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
10	Romancing Nadine 2020Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible
11	A New Love for Charlotte 2021Buy 🇺🇸🎧 Audible